- NCTE Publications Home
- Subjects
- English Language Arts/ Research
English Language Arts/ Research
Extending the Conversation: Raising Issues of Rurality in English Teacher Education
Situated within the challenges faced by English teacher educators in the frontier state of Montana this article argues for the need for increased attention to issues of ruralitywithin the field of English education. Conceptualizing rural education as an issue of social justice the article suggests several approaches English teacher educators andresearchers might take in thinking about rural English education including integrating readings related to rurality in English education coursework researching the uniquechallenges of teacher identity formation within rural contexts and emphasizing research focused on rural youth literacy practices.
Embodying English: Performing and Positioning the White Teacher in a High School English Class
Recent research and theoretical work on whiteness in teaching highlights reific monolithic discourses that position white teachers as deficient resistant naive and ignorant. I seek to complicate similar reductive portrayals through a two-year case of one high school teacher’s racial identities and subjectivities in and beyond the English classroom. Drawing on post-structural performance theories of identity and subjectivity I pinpoint the material and sociopolitical forces that constrainthe white teaching body and reorient attention to the power of people in daily motion: subverting making themselves known in multiple ways always and already becoming. This performative perspective may provide productive lenses for white teachers in antiracist higher education who support teachers living and working in white skin.
Enacting High Leverage Practices in English Methods: The Case of Discussion
Though literature discussions are a commonplace feature of English classrooms we know little about how teachers learn to facilitate classroom talk. Research on methods courses reveals little about how or if teachers are prepared to enact the “high leverage” practice of literature discussions. This qualitative study examines an English methods unit on discussion and the practices that the novices later enacted in the field. Sociocultural theory is used to analyze how the novices’enacted particular features of discussions and how these activities afforded them opportunities to practice the facilitative roles that teachers play. The findings suggest that the novices had difficulty understanding their roles as teachers in student-centered activities and that teacher educators must curricularize enactments to help novices learn what teachers actually do when enacting high leverage practices like discussions.
Opening the Conversation: Thoughts on Transitions
The editors introduce the content of this issue.
Building Multiliterate and Multilingual Writing Practices and Identities
This article describes an adolescent’s development of multiliterate and multilingual writing practices and identities. It further explores how a literacy teacher enacted a writing pedagogy of multiliteracies that assisted the youth in building writing practices and identities. Data include interviews of the young woman and her teacher classroom observations and literacy artifacts produced and used by the adolescent. These data are analyzed using theories of identity positioning communities of practice and multiliteracies. Findings include that the youth developed her writing practices and identities over time and across multiple contexts of multiliterate and multilingual practices. Within and across these communities the dimensions of apprenticeship positioning and recruitment of multiliterate and multilingual repertoires were essential to the youth’s development of writing practices and identities. These dimensions were also central to the literacy teacher’s enactment of a writing pedagogy of multiliteracies. The article asserts that attending to the processes through which young people develop their multiliterate and multilingual repertoires and identities can assist educators in creating supportive literacy environments for youth. It offers recommendations for literacy scholars and educators in this regard.
Extending the Conversation: Why Does He Want a Dictator? Action Research on Democratic Classroom Decision Making
This article extends the conversation on English education as preparation for democratic participation. The author journeys through a cycle of action research analyzing one classroom case study to improve her practice of curricular negotiation in a methods of teaching writing course.
Opening the Conversation: Connecting across Classrooms, Communities, and Disciplines
The editors introduce the content of this issue.
All the Ways of Reading Literature: Preservice English Teachers’ Perspectives on Disciplinary Literacy
In recent years the field of literacy education and research has seen an increased attention to disciplinary literacy instruction—the teaching of discipline-specific and valued ways of reading writing knowing and communicating knowledge. This article is about disciplinary literacy specifically disciplinary reading as it is understood by preservice teachers of English language arts. Data were collected from two cohorts of preservice English teachers (2010–2011; 2011–2012). Qualitative content analysis of preservice teachers’ writings and interview data suggests that “reading” in the discipline of English encompasses a range of approaches to texts. It can mean paying attention to the language and form of the text or exploring the social and cultural worlds within the work. It can also mean applying different interpretive lenses such as the lens of race class gender or culture. Much of the data also contained preservice teachers’ ideas for and concerns about teaching disciplinary literacy to adolescents. Insight into preservice teachers’ perspectives on disciplinary literacy can support the work of teacher educators student teaching supervisors and mentor teachers.
Urban Fiction and Multicultural Literature as Transformative Tools for Preparing English Teachers for Diverse Classrooms
Discussions of urban fiction and multicultural literature hold great potential for transforming the practice of beginning English teachers in diverse school settings. In this article the authorsboth teacher educators of color present two case studies of preparing middle- and secondary-level English educators from a diversities perspective. Given continued conversations in the field of English education on how to best prepare new teachers for working effectively with diverse student populations the authors present situated representations of how teachers’ critical encounters with literature can shape their learning to teach processes from the university classroom to their field experiences. Both case studies presented have a particular interest in the critical theoretical and pedagogical insights developed by preservice teachers through their discussions of children’s and adolescent literature that deals with diverse urban and multicultural perspectives. In doing so these case studies reposition urban fiction and multicultural literature as transformative tools for teacher education curriculum.
Opening the Conversation: Thinking Deeper about Text Selection
Editors Leslie Rush and Lisa Scherff along with graduate student Christine Maddox Martorana discuss issues related to text selection and introduce the articles in this issue.
Supernovas and Superheroes: Examining Unfamiliar Genres and Teachers’ Pedagogical Content Knowledge
Within the field of writing teacher education scholars and practitioners agree that effective writing instructors (at both the P–12 and postsecondary levels) are not simply cognizant of composition pedagogies rhetorical theories and their students’ unique learning needs. Effective writing instructors also regularly participate—themselves—in the practice of writing. As Tom Romano (2007) explains “Those who teach a craft ought to do a craft. When teachers of writing write particularly in the genres they teach they develop their insider knowledge” (p. 171). Realistically many inservice English language arts teachers do not have an extensive amount of time to write reflect on their writing and translate their “insider knowledge” into pedagogical practices. One place where this type of writing-teaching reflection and development may occur however is in the postsecondary classroom. This article describes a graduate-level methods course in which middle-grades and secondary-level ELA teachers completed two projects focused on analyzing composing and teaching an unfamiliar genre. This study extends current research regarding the use of unfamiliar genres to improve students’ writing proficiencies (Bastian 2010; Beckelhimer 2011; Fleischer & Andrew-Vaughan 2006 2009) by adapting these projects to a new group of writers: inservice ELA teachers. Using a qualitative research design this study draws upon Grossman’s (1990) theoretical framework and pedagogical content knowledge to name and define four specific ways in which the course’s unfamiliar genre projects promoted teachers’ “insider knowledge” as writers thus affecting their beliefs and practices for teaching writing.
Extending the Conversation: The Ethics of Teaching Disturbing Pasts: Reader Response, Historical Contextualization, and Rhetorical (Con)Textualization of Holocaust Texts in English
A set of especially complicated ethical relationships becomes visible in literary study when the unspeakable atrocity of state-sponsored genocide is part of the story as it is in many wartime texts taught in secondary English classrooms. What then is the nature of an English teacher’s obligation to the detailed particularity of the past and to those who endured that past whenencouraging students’ individual and collaborative responses to texts in the present (or in the future)? I explore the broad ethical question by discussing specific difficulties presented by the case of Holocaust pedagogy. The guiding purpose of the discussion is to explore a set of more general questions about the ethical dimensions of literary engagement in English—and specifically engagement with texts about disturbing pasts.
Competing Centers of Gravity: A Beginning English Teacher’s Socialization Process within Conflictual Settings
This case study follows a teacher candidate through her semester of student teaching English in a suburban high school in the U.S. Southeast. The study is part of a line of inquiry that investigates the factors that contribute to teachers’ development of concepts to guide their instruction. In particular this research focuses on the mediational role of settings in teachers’ development of a teaching conception and the attributions made by the teacher candidate to the sources for her understanding of how to teach. Data for the research consist of observations and interviews with focal teacher Anita and key stakeholders. These data were analyzed to identify the pedagogical tools used during student teaching and the sources to which she attributed her learning of them. Findings indicate that Anita’s initial conception of teaching was complicated by competing centers of gravity—that is settings with conflicting notions of effective practice—that pulled her in many different directions thus making her ability to develop a coherent approach to teaching a challenge. The study concludes with a discussion of conventional linear views of concept development and how attention to the settings of learning to teach can help explain the difficulties of learning to teach in cohesive and consistent ways.
Opening the Conversation: The Common Core and Effective Literacy Education
The editors look at the CCSS and what they mean for literacy educators. Also included are responses from two doctoral students Allison Wynhoff Olsen and Emily A. Nemeth to two of the articles in this issue and to the Common Core State Standards.
“Starting with What Is”: Exploring Response and Responsibility to Student Writing through Collaborative Inquiry
This article examines student teachers’ investigations of issues related to writing pedagogy response and evaluation in an English methods course including their use of descriptive review of student writing (Carini 2001) to analyze adolescents’ work collaboratively. Beginning with an examination of prevailing understandings of writing assessment and common instructional models in schools the article explores critical inquiry–based approaches. This research documents how collaborative investigations encouraged student teachers to explore meaning and intentionality in student writing and to regard students as authors with intentionality and purpose. Findings substantiate adolescents’ and student teachers’ intellectual and experiential resources suggesting how these can be a foundation for expanding conceptions and practices related to writing pedagogy assessment inquiry-based teaching and teacher education.
Extending the Conversation: Experience Over All: Preservice Teachers and the Prizing of the “Practical”
The authors consider how preservice teachers and teacher educators might broaden their operating notions of experience and practicality to help one another access a wider range of sources of knowledge for their teaching.
English Education 2.0: An Analysis of Websites That Contain Videos of English Teaching
In this article we address how websites intended for ELA teachers encourage user participation and what kinds of English education these sites promote or exclude. We selected sites based on assumptions drawn from interactional sociolinguistics as well as additional criteria that developed during our search. Our analysis focuseson the George Lucas Foundation’s Edutopia.org as a central example as well as five other sites with various similar features. Together these sites promote a progressive situated project-based vision of English teaching and they may serve as both venues and models for how English teacher educators who share that vision can reach a broader audience.
Opening the Conversation: With Whom Might We Partner? For What Ends? In What Contexts? With What Reach?
In this editorial we asked two experienced English teachers to provide responses to the two research articles in this issue. In this way all of the pieces in the issue point to the importance of collaboration for different stakeholders in English teacher preparation.
Extending the Conversation: Building Insider Knowledge: Teaching Students to Read, Write, and think within ELA and across the Disciplines
We offer this article to support ELA and other subject-area teachers as they think about why disciplinary literacy teaching is important and how to enact it in robust ways. We argue that it is critical for the improvement of students’ academic literacy development and overall learning that all teachers and literacy researchers attend to the teaching of disciplinary literacy in every subject area.
“Anything Could Happen”: Managing Uncertainty in an Academic Writing Partnership
This article describes a writing partnership that involved university preservice teachers and ninthgradestudents enrolled in an integrated social studies/language arts class. While the high schoolstudents found the experience exciting and satisfying the preservice teachers expressed anxietiesand concerns as they endeavored to foster academic literacies. We conclude with reflections onthe challenges of preparing a new generation of English educators to teach writing in rich andmeaningful ways where they have not themselves benefited from such experiences in their own “apprenticeships of observation.”
Developing Understandings of Race: Preservice Teachers’ Counter-Narrative (Re)Constructions of People of Color in Young Adult Literature
This qualitative study reveals the ways in which reading and reflecting on two counter-narrative young adult novels fostered opportunities for preservice English teachers to think more acutely about their understandings of race within and beyond the text. Participants expressed feelings of empathy with and connection to characters whose cultural realities are different from their own. This emphasis on the universal human condition and transcendent power of literature suggests the potential of counter-narrative literature to allow participants to connect with characters across lines of difference. In addition participants provided evidence of how the counter-narratives encouraged them to reconsider assumptions that society and they hold and perpetuate relative to people of color. The texts offered readers a new way in which to reconceptualize societal norms to reconsider how they see the seeming “other” and in some cases recognize their own culpability in promoting existing stereotypes. Finally the counter-narrative texts heightened participants’ awareness of Whiteness the ways in which race can privilege or limit by fostering insider or outsider status and the discomfort that can result when such dichotomies define our identities. Findings illuminate the complexities inherent in the development of understandings of race among preservice teachers and reveal a richer understanding of preservice teachers’ development of knowledge related to the educational needs of students of color and their attitudes toward these students in and out of the classroom.
Extending the Conversation: English Teachers, Administrators, and Dialogue: Transcending the Asymmetry of Power in the Discourse of Educational Policy
In this article I present six English teachers’ perceptions of the dialogue used by principals and superintendents to communicate policy mandates in their schools. I wanted to learn about the ways in which the discourse employed by these two kinds of policymakers influenced English teachers’ experiences as professionals and how these policies and the language used to convey them influenced the teachers’ autonomy and their instructional decisions. I found that these teachers perceived that policymakers employed an authoritative discourse (Bakhtin 1981 1986a) that made it difficult for them to engage in dialogue with the policy mandates they received. Bowe Ball and Gold (1992) characterized policy as a discourse that functions as “a set of claims about how the world should and might be a matter of the authoritative allocation of values” (p. 370). I foreground the voices of secondary English teachers to generate dialogue focused on reconceptualizing the nature of policy discourse in U.S. schools.
Opening the Conversation: Looking Back at 2011 to Inform 2012
Editors Scherff and Rush introduce the issue and its themes.
Negotiating the Rub between Cultures: Teacher Talk and Sustained Shifts in Practice
This article examines the outcomes of an eight-month professional development initiative designed to support six Writing Project teachers’ classroom inquiry projects each focused on improving an aspect of student writing. We begin by introducing the genesis of these classroom research projects as well as the structure and content of the support program consisting of seven two-hour sessions between October 2009 and April 2010. Data consisted of observations of these sessions and teacher interviews. We report the successes and challenges of this learning community in supporting teachers’ professional growth. Findings uncover the barriers participants faced while working toward classroom inquiry goals and suggest the importance of community critical structured discussion and active problem solving in developing teachers’ confidence. We close by discussing the implications of this study for professional development in schools.
Opening the Conversation: Maintaining Collegiality in Tough Times
Editors Scherff and Rush introduce the issue and its themes.
Deficits, Therapists, and a Desire to Distance: Secondary English Preservice Teachers’ Reasoning about their Future Students
This article explores how secondary English preservice teachers reason about their future students and the consequences these systems of reasoning have for their thinking about pedagogy and their roles as teachers. By examining these systems of reasoning this article helps to denaturalize normalized discourses about adolescence—discourses that oftentimes help to name and positionyoung people in powerful predictable and problematic ways. Finally this article suggests ways English teacher educators might create spaces for preservice literacy teachers to rethink how their experiences with adolescents are always mediated and produced by discourses that authorize how young people are known and acted upon.
Extending the Conversation: The State of English Education: Considering Possibilities in Troubled Times
For the “Extending the Conversation” section in this issue we invited English educators from the United States and abroad to reflect on the state of English education in their countries. All five contributors have interacted through their participation in the NCTE Annual Convention the CEE summer summits the International Federation for the Teaching of English (IFTE) convention and the NATE conference. We begin with initial thoughts by Shaun Hawthorne the Deputy Principal at Western Springs College in Auckland New Zealand; and Andy Goodwyn a faculty member at the University of Reading in England. Then Marshall George (Fordham University) Louann Reid (Colorado State University) and Melanie Shoffner (Purdue University) offer a “trialogue” in response. We hope these perspectives give readers insight into international contexts and advance dialogue in English education.
Exploring the Significance of Social Class Identity Performance in the English Classroom: A Case Study Analysis of a Literature Circle Discussion
English educators at all levels have endeavored to understand difference in their classrooms both in terms of the content that they teach and in terms of the social and cultural identities of students in their classrooms. However although educators have come a long way in understanding identity as it is constituted by race and gender much work is needed for social class identity to be understood with nuance and complexity. This article explores the salience of class identity as it affects one aspect of learning in the English classroom—literary interpretation. Specifically this article draws on data from a six-week literature circle unit in which four white socioeconomically diverse students discussed Dorothy Allison’s Bastard Out of Carolina. By examining and uncovering the students’ social class identity performances as they influenced both their participation and interpretations in the literature circle this article sheds light on the significance of social class identity in the English classroom and makes a case for the importance of a more thorough consideration of social class in teaching and research in English education.
Extending the Conversation: Writing as Praxis
In his address from the 2011 CEE Summer Conference at Fordham University Yagelski challenges us to refocus our efforts at education reform and literacy instruction to emphasize the "humanness of schooling."
“A Rainforest in Front of a Bulldozer”: The Literacy Practices of Teacher Candidates Committed to Social Justice
This critical ethnographic study explores how two teacher candidates in English education used specific and varied literacy practices to enact their social justice priorities at a troubled high school in a high-need district. Data include interviews before and after the student teaching experience; observations of teaching blogs journals and emails; and coursework required of candidates. Critical discourse analysis was used to analyze the data. The New Literacy Studies and teaching for social justice frameworks were foundational to this research. In addition the theory of testimonial reading as outlined by Felman (1992) and Boler (1999) was used to demonstrate how the two candidates worked within and against the system to resist deficit models of their students and ultimately bear witness to their students’ experiences.
Living the Poet’s Life: Using an Aesthetic Approach to Poetry to Enhance Preservice Teachers’ Poetry Experiences and Dispositions
In this article we argue that preservice teachers have limited experience reading and writing poetry and that if they are to teach poetry in meaningful ways to their future students they need to have compelling experiences with poetry in teacher education—ones that take into account their former experiences and incoming dispositions and that invite them to begin to live “the life of a poet.” We designed a poetry course for 23 junior and senior elementary middle school and secondary school English language arts majors to provide them with such a set of experiences. Although incoming preservice teachers reported limited often negative previous experiences with poetry we found that using what we came to call an “aesthetic approach” improved both their experiences with and their dispositions toward reading writing and performing poetry. Using a qualitative research design we drew on Boyer’s notion of the scholarship of teaching (1990) to address three research questions: (1) What are preservice teachers’ perceptions of past experiences with poetry? (2) What dispositions (that is attitudes and habits) toward poetry reading writing and performance do preservice teachers have? (3) How can an aesthetic approach enhance preservice teachers’ experiences with and dispositions toward poetry? Based on this research we recommend that teacher education not only include substantive coursework on the topic of poetry but that the pedagogy of such a course approximate to the extent possible practicing poets’ engagement with the genre.
Extending the Conversation: English Teacher Education as Literacy Teacher Education
In Mayher's keynote address from the 2011 CEE Summer Conference at Fordham University he challenges us to rethink what we do and how we do it.
Extending the Conversation: In Search of the Authentic English Classroom: Facing the Schoolishness of School
Anne Elrod Whitney’s first-person narrative about her experiences as a student teacher and teacher educator gives us a sense of what authenticity in classrooms might look like and what it might mean for students.
Editorial: Opening the Conversation: Thoughts on English Teacher Preparation and Renewal with Patricia Lambert Stock, Ruth Vinz, and David Schaafsma, Past EE Editors
For the final installment of our co-written editorials with former English Education editors and in honor of the centennial anniversary of the National Council of Teachers of English we offer responses by Patricia Lambert Stock Ruth Vinz and David Schaafsma to the question “How can the profession improve the preparation and renewal of all English educators?”
“White People Don’t Work at McDonald’s” and Other Shadow Stories from the Field: Analyzing Preservice Teachers’ Use of Obama’s Race Speech to Teach for Social Justice
This study investigates the outcomes of two novice preservice teachers’ (PSTs’) attempts at taking up the roles of critical guides (Damico & Apol 2008) to mediate discussions about racism inresponse to President Barack Obama’s (2008) campaign speech “A More Perfect Union.” With the objective of teaching for social justice these PSTs initiated their discussions in two senior English classrooms at the same high school located in a predominantly white economically low-middle-class Midwest community. Profiles of each intern were developed from data comprised of field notes meeting notes interviews video and audio recordings journal entries essays and other artifacts. Framed by Damico and Apol’s (2008) concept for mediating historical risky texts and grounded in the principles of critical literacy and antiracist pedagogy this investigation demonstrates that despite their objective to teach social justice the PSTs enacted discussions that generated shadow texts (Simon 2000) and perpetuated stereotypes. It suggests that for these PSTs there may be a disconnection between the theories they learned in their teacher preparation courses and their practical application of such theories in the field.
Extending the Conversation: Applying the CEE Position Statement Beliefs about Social Justice in English Education to Classroom Praxis
The authors provide a fresh look at the CEE position statement on social justice in English education by articulating how social justice education works in their disparate settings.
Opening the Conversation: What Is English? Revisiting the Nature of Our Discipline with Past Editors Allen Berger and Gordon Pradl
In this issue we feature the third of four guest editorials in honor of NCTE’s 100th anniversary. We welcome Allen Berger who was editor from 1979 to 1986 and Gordon Pradl who was coeditor—along with Mary K. Healey—from 1986 to 1993. As with the January and April editorials we asked our former editors to respond to a question from one of their own editorials: What is English? How do student achievement and teacher competency affect the public’s perception of what it means to be an English teacher?
Service Learning and the Preparation of English Teachers
In this article service learning is explored as a pedagogical third space from which preservice teachers learn to teach the New English education. We argue that such a space has the potential to foster preservice English teachers’ understanding of their role and identity as future teachers and how this identity is always relative to the students they teach. Drawing from a study of 19 preservice English teachers’ experiences with service learning we discuss three themes relevant to service learning and the preparation of English teachers: (1) service learning as a pedagogical third space for English teachers (2) service learning as fostering the disruption of a teaching mythology and (3) service learning as promoting a recognition of the New English education. Further we propose that service learning can encourage prospective English teachers to complicate notions of teacher/student official/unofficial language singular authority/pluralistic power and server/served.
The Vulnerable Population of Teacher-Researchers; Or, “Why I Can’t Name My Coauthors”
Educational researchers are accustomed to institutional review board (IRB) requirements (e.g. protecting participants) with students often identified as the only “vulnerable population” for IRB purposes. However as practitioner research has gained more prominence the vulnerability of teacher-researchers themselves has begun to surface. In this article I tell the stories of teachers who felt ostracized as a result of engaging in research and publication. Drawing on research from Scandinavia and Australia I present some reasons why teachers might seek to “cut down” colleagues who conduct and publish research. Finally I present suggestions for university-based researchers and teacher educators who wish to help practitioner researchers prepare for any potential backlash as well as some questions for future research.
Extending the Conversation: Seeing Our City, Students, and School: Using Photography to Engage Diverse Youth with Our English Classes
In this article a team of English teachers and teacher educators reflect on both their involvement with the photovoice project Through Students’ Eyes (TSE) and on the photographic and written data of their students’ perspectives on school. After working with hundreds of youth involved with TSE for most of the past decade they consider why they have been involved with the project what it has meant for them as English teachers the nature of their university/school collaborations how the project has mattered to their students and how it might matter to other English educators. The authors describe how they have gained knowledge of their students maintained a professional humility and recognized the importance of asking youth and themselves about the value of school.
Extending the Conversation: Using Theater to Engage Cultural Identity: Implications for Students and Teachers
David Blazar shares his experiences teaching a unit based on the Broadway musical In the Heights as a way of engaging the cultural identity of his students mainly Dominican Americans. He learned much about his students as a result enabling him to connect with them as people but also to encourage their specific needs as students thinkers and writers.
Editorial: Opening the Conversation: A Reflection and Commentary with Past Editor Cathy Fleischer
Past editor Fleischer reflects on questions central to the field of English education. The articles is this issue are then introduced.
“Why Do You Think That?” A Supervisor’s Mediation of a Preservice English Teacher’s Understanding of Instructional Scaffolding
This article reports a study of a university supervisor and a preservice English language arts teacher as they worked collaboratively within two different field experience sites to develop a conceptual understanding of instructional scaffolding. An analysis of classroom observations and mentoring conversations was conducted to examine how the supervisor supported the preservice teacher’s transfer of tools for instruction from a university program to the high school classroom. Findings indicate the significant role of the teacher education program’s conceptual base in fostering this transfer.
Teaching Grammar and Writing: A Beginning Teacher’s Dilemma
This longitudinal case study follows one high school English teacher’s path of concept development over a two-year period encompassing her student teaching and first year of full-time teaching both at the same rural school in the southeastern United States. The authors use a sociocultural theoretical framework emerging from the work of Vygotsky to focus on the construction of activity settings and the ways in which settings help to shape concept development. In particular the analysis finds the teacher drawing on apparently inconsistent pedagogical traditions and their associated mediational tools: one centered on a teacher’s authoritarian control of the curriculum and adherence to formal properties of texts and one centered on students’ interests and their agency in learning.
Emerging Practice for New Teachers: Creating Possibilities for “Aesthetic” Readings
This article explores how exposure to aesthetic education approaches can help novice teachers reconsider their literature instruction in an age of mandated curricula and increased pressures to“teach to the test.” The guiding questions were as follows: What similarities exist between transacting with a text on the page and aesthetically engaging with other works of art and could thesetheories and practices be brought into ELA classrooms? Through freewrites reflective papers and a final self-assessment students documented both their initial resistances and their evolvingunderstandings of aesthetic education. We discovered that involving English education students in aesthetic experiences affected the ways many began to reimagine their classrooms literacy/literature instruction and education in general.
Opening the Conversation: A Dialogue with Past Editors Ben Nelms and Michael Moore
Current editors Leslie Rush and Lisa Scherff talk to past editors Ben Nelms and Michael Moore about ongoing issues in English education.
Extending the Conversation: Writing Wounded: Trauma, Testimony, and Critical Witness in Literacy Classrooms
Elizabeth Dutro emphasizes the importance of acknowledging the “hard stuff” of life in our classrooms.
Rejoining the Learning Circle: When Inservice Providers Conduct Research
In this article a group of inservice providers and beginning researchers describe their experiences in learning to conduct evaluation research on a long-term school-university partnership program. We offer the practical lessons we learned in how to undertake such a study and we share the immediate and powerful effects that the process of conducting the research had on the way we envisionand enact our inservice work. As the director of the inservice program noted the problem we were addressing changed from “How can we convince others that we do good work?” to “How canwe make our work better?” This is a question at the heart of professional learning communities.
“A Respect for the Past, a Knowledge of the Present, and a Concern for the Future”: The Role of History in English Education
This article argues that ELA teacher candidates and inservice ELA teachers need historical perspectives in their coursework and their practice. Using the life and career of Lou LaBrant the authorexamines the value of placing current practice in the context of practice throughout the history of the field of teaching ELA. Patterns examined in LaBrant’s life and work include the historicaltension between bureaucracy and teacher empowerment back-to-basics movements the roles of research and progressivism in the field of literacy and the relationship between educational andsocial challenges. Further the article examines avenues for teacher educators to become more connected with the history of the field.
Writing for the Public: Teacher Editorializing as a Pathway to Professional Development
Teacher-written editorial columns in local newspapers can challenge the broad simplistic conceptions of the profession that have been encouraged by contemporary politics and that obscure the real work of teachers. The publication of such columns written by a diverse group of teachers in the West Texas Writing Project has proved an important tool for fostering a stronger sense of professionalism in individual teachers and for promoting their expertise to the lay public and other educators in their community. It has also afforded teachers new models and tools for teaching writing to their own students. This article argues that English education faculty and teacher educators are uniquely qualified to help teachers develop their political voices and write about education issues for the public and it provides readers with methodologies for preparing teachers to do so. In addition an analysis of four teacher-written columns sets out specific roles teachers can envision and assume in advocating for school reform and in taking greater ownership over their work. For teachers such as these an enhanced professionalism that comes from writing for the public about their education objectives is an important step in developing teacher leadership skills.
Positioning Students as Readers and Writers through Talk in a High School English Classroom
This 5-month qualitative study investigates how one high school English teacher situated students as readers and writers within daily spontaneous classroom interactions. Specifically the author draws on positioning theory (van Langenhove & Harré 1999) as a lens to analyze how the teacher navigated improvised responses during three separate literacy events to position students as engaged readers capable writers and members of a writing community. This approach construes that literacy learning is an identity process in which language is a powerful medium. Results from the study suggest that teachers must be sophisticated navigators of improvised interactions to facilitate the process of literacy learning. Vetter offers suggestions to teacher educators about how to implement critical analysis of classroom interactions and improvised responses to improve literacy instruction.
Seeing, Inquiring, Witnessing: Using the Equity Audit in Practitioner Inquiry to Rethink Inequity in Public Schools
In this classroom research piece Groenke explains how she uses an equity audit with her preservice teachers to generate ideas for action research studies they later complete.
Teaching English Education and Lurching Forward
Shadiow tells of an event that shifted her perspective on teaching methods courses and repositioned her teaching to focus on student learning.
English Education Program Assessment: Creating Standards and Guidelines to Advance English Teacher Preparation
In this dialogue with policymakers Zancanella and Alsup write about Cee’s recent activities related to teacher preparation guidelines.
Opening the Conversation
The new editors introduce themselves and the current issue.
Developing Investigative Entry Points: Exploring the Use of Quantitative Methods in English Education Research
The authors share how statistics and quantitative methods can inform compliment and/or deepen out inquiries.
Critical Conversations: Tensions and Opportunities of the Dialogical Classroom
English teachers and educators of English teachers should work within rather than against the tensions present in their classrooms. For us nothing could be more key. Until university teacher educators construct and enact classrooms that embrace the dialogical tensions and possibilities within those settings new and veteran teachers in the profession will have few if any sustained experiences upon which to base their own dialogical classrooms. Moreover to either deny that tensions exist or to struggle to eradicate them is to misunderstand the purpose and possibility of tension. Learners caught between stabilizing and destabilizing tensions enter a state of wobble one that asks them to pay attention to the issues at hand and to author a response. The goal is not to remove oneself from that tension but instead to enter into a dialogue that like the cables on a suspension bridge uses tension for support and equilibrium.
Cultural Citizenship and Cosmopolitan Practice: Global Youth Communicate Online
Calls now abound in a range of literatures “philosophy education sociology anthropology media studies;” to reimagine citizenship and identity in ways befitting a global age. A concept predominant in many such calls is the ancient idea of cosmopolitanism. Refashioned now to serve as a compass in a world that is at once radically interconnected and increasingly divided a cosmopolitan point of view remains resiliently hopeful asserting that people can both uphold local commitments and take into consideration larger arenas of concern. This article animates theorizing about cultural citizenship identity formation and communication with an examination of what might be considered sites for cosmopolitan practice’ an online international social network and offline local programs designed to engage youth in representing themselves and interacting with the representations of others. Specifically we report our initial research with a group of teenage girls in India tracing their participation online and offline and their cosmopolitan imaginings of self and other. We hope that this work with young people worlds away geographically culturally and ideologically will speak to English educators in the United States who feel likewise compelled to support their students in developing twenty-first-century literacies’ both the technological competencies and the values knowledge and dispositions’needed to participate confidently and critically as citizens of local and global worlds.
Preservice Teachers Planning for Critical Literacy Teaching
This case reflects a yearlong project I as the instructor of an Advanced Methods course conducted with my students to help them plan and implement critical literacy units in their high school and middle school student teaching placements. To do so I assigned student teachers to explore notions of critical literacy (including resistant reading marginalized perspectives and social action projects) and then use these methods to create and teach critical literacy units over two semesters. Students then uploaded these units along with their reflections to electronic portfolios. This research explores how these student teachers defined critical literacy for themselves and then planned implemented and reflected on their units.
Dialogic Praxis in Teacher Preparation: A Discourse Analysis of Mentoring Talk
This study examined the complexities of mentoring discourse and agentive teacher preparation. I argue that such an examination is necessary to better prepare student teachers to engage agentively with the powerful status quo in schools. I begin by discussing the intersections of current thinking about mentoring and dialogue and I describe how these intersections suggest productive avenues for analyzing mentoring discourse. I then use a conceptualization of “dialogic praxis” to look closely at one instance of mentoring talk. Finally I suggest this study’s implications for teacher preparation research practice and policy.
(Re)visioning U.S. Latino Literatures in High School English Classrooms
In focusing on what is taught in English language arts Rojas examines stereotypical notions of U. S. Latino cultures and identities and finds that there is considerable diversity within the group that is worthy of acknowledgment.
Texting Identities: Lessons for Classrooms from Multiethnic Youth Space
Paris examines texts worn on objects (like clothing or backpacks) delivered over electronic media and rapped by youth emcees at a multiethnic high school. He argues that these are identity texts used by young people to express ethnic and linguistic differences.
Static Structures, Changing Demographics: Educating Teachers for Shifting Populations in Stable Schools
Portes and Smagorinsky examine the degree to which stable schools and authoritarian instruction accommodate the needs of learners exhibiting difference with special attention to Spanish-speaking English Language Learners in a Southern setting. They find that the influx of immigrant students in Southern schools lays bare the normative institutional structures and instructional practices that go unchallenged until a new cultural group enters the school and reveals that what is normative to some is alien to others.
English(es) in Urban Contexts: Politics, Pluralism, and Possibilities
This issue’s guest editor offers thoughts on the changing linguistic spaces of society by attempting to map the pluralistic dynamic and fluid nature of new English(es) as used by urban youth.
Teaching English Learners: Building on Cultural and Linguistic Strengths
Souto-Manning examines the role of classroom discourse analysis in helping to change a teacher’s perceptions of English Language Learners from students who need “fixing” to experts from whom teachers may learn. She finds that blurring the lines between teacher/student and subject/object positions opens up pedagogical third spaces that are often missing from traditional classrooms.
The Editorial We: Teaching English in a Sea of Change: Linguistic Pluralism and the New English Education
Guest editor David Kirkland introduces this themed issue on linguistic pluralism which grew out of a set of conversations initiated by the 2006’2008 NCTE Cultivating New Voices Fellows.
An Afterword: Opening Curricular Closets in Regulated Times: Finding Pedagogical Keys
Anne Haas Dyson concludes the issue by challenging readers to see the diversity of languages within which one’s own voice sounds.
Texts, Talk … and Fear? English Language Arts Teachers Negotiate Social Justice Teaching
Delane Bender-Slack takes on the important subject of teaching for social justice. Her article’s strength is in its uncompromising look at complex often misinterpreted teaching challenges. This article focuses on actual teachers working for social justice in their classrooms. Working from a strongtheoretical framework she pushes us in new directions to understand the growing complexities in teaching for social justice.
Merging Beliefs of Classroom Teachers and Teacher Educators
Joseph O. Milner explores a narrowing of differences between English teacher educators and classroom teachers. Using North Carolina as anational barometer for his action research Milner cites the shifting attitudes of classroom teachers toward the shared values of English teacher educators and he opens the door for similar research projects in other states.
Deconstructing ’Aesthetic Response’ in Small-Group Discussions about Literature: A Possible Solution to the “Aesthetic Response” Dilemma
Anna Soter and colleagues push the response to literature limits by first exploring; expressive response to account for readers’ personal connection to literature and offering a “third space” that; any reader might make at different times and for different reasons.’ This third space causes us to reconsider the work that aesthetic response has been doing all along in responses readers make to literature.
Globalizing English through Intercultural Critical Literacy
This article examines the construction of an intercultural critical literacy practice in a Web-based discussion forum as one way to globalize interpretive practices within the English classroom.; English education students in the United States and Sweden discussed a short story over a period of three weeks.; The analysis of the students’ postings identified five patterns of an intercultural critical literacy practice in which global readers identify and critique the cultural values and beliefs they use to interpret texts and understand their own lives.; Knowledge of the characteristics of an intercultural critical literacy practice can assist English educators in the construction of similar global interactions and critical practices with their students.
On the Horns of a Dilemma: Deweyan Progressivism and English Teacher Education
English teacher educators’ commitment to Deweyan progressivism has cost them in recent years. It has contributed to their being pushed to the margins when it comes to serious top-level discussions about the direction of American education. This essay reexamines the case for progressivism and its relevance as an element of CEE’s ongoing effort to reinterpret itself since the 2005 CEE Summit.
Addressing the Needs of English Language Learners in an English Education Methods Course
Firmly anchored in methods course construction Luciana de Oliveira and Melanie Shoffner’s article is a starting point in the discussion of better preparing English teachers to help diverse learners. It offers both practical considerations and implications for needed research.