College English - Volume 61, Issue 1, 1998

Discusses Willa Cather’s novel “Lucy Gayheart,” which provides the only public access to Cather’s sense of connection to Virginia Woolf, a writer she admired. Uses Cather’s “provocative” placement of Mrs. Ramsay as a way to re-frame thinking about this novel. Considers it as an experimental modernist novel.

States that a number of college literature and composition teachers have shown that they care intensely about ethical issues, although they express themselves in the language of postmodernism rather than that of traditional ethics. Claims the traditional ethical goal of building “character” can be harmonized with the postmodern effort to build “selves”--persons with a “useful” ethical center.

Contends that the academy has forgotten the origin of the dissertation and has turned it from a substantive contribution of scholarship to an instrument of evaluation. Argues that continuing to treat the dissertation in this way maintains an unequal power hierarchy of “masters” and initiates–it should be seen as the first serious scholarly monograph a scholar produces.

Available in print version only.